Document the disk health field

Records why there are two sources and why they are not reconciled, so the next person does not simplify the ATA SMART path back in and silently blind the fleet on NVMe hardware.

Also notes that diskhealth is per physical device and is not the same list as disks, and that a null predictfailure is unknown rather than healthy.
This commit is contained in:
benjamin.baker
2026-09-05 06:26:06 -04:00
parent c2ec29e236
commit 71847d940a
2 changed files with 52 additions and 4 deletions

View File

@@ -136,8 +136,25 @@ inventory-snapshot plumbing and one migration.
Root Dispersion in the same seconds format BEFORE Phase Offset, so a
first-match parser silently reports network latency as clock skew. That bug
was written and caught here; do not rewrite it.
- **Disk errors / SMART predictive failure** - collect and surface on the
existing Storage card (Phase 4).
- **Disk errors / SMART predictive failure** - DONE. Landed as its own "Disk
health" card rather than folded into the Storage card as originally planned:
Storage is per VOLUME (C:, D:) and this is per PHYSICAL device, and one drive
can back several volumes or none the operator sees, so the two do not share a
key and could not be one table.
The important finding: the classic ATA SMART class
(`MSStorageDriver_FailurePredictStatus`) returns ZERO instances on an NVMe
machine. Verified on a two-NVMe box where both drives were present and
healthy. An agent collecting only that class would have reported an empty
disk health list on every modern endpoint and read as "no problems" - the
exact silent-healthy failure mode this telemetry exists to prevent. So the
agent collects BOTH `MSFT_PhysicalDisk` (the only NVMe-aware source) and
`Win32_DiskDrive.Status` (ATA/SATA, and hosts where the Storage namespace is
unavailable), and the server does not reconcile them - same reasoning as the
Phase 1 mapped-drive merge, where two disagreeing sources was the signal.
Note `MSFT_PhysicalDisk` returns raw enum INTEGERS through
ManagementObjectSearcher, not the friendly strings `Get-PhysicalDisk` prints
(Health=0 Op=2 Media=4 Bus=17 for a healthy NVMe); the mapping lives in the
collector so the wire stays self-describing.
- **NIC link speed and duplex** - collect, pair into the existing Network
interfaces collection, NOT surfaced yet.
- **Boot type** - fast startup vs true cold boot. Explains why uptime lies and
@@ -199,8 +216,12 @@ Depends on Phase 2 data existing.
- **Mapped drives card** - `Get-SmbMapping`-shaped. `Disconnected` in red,
`Ok` in green. Reuse existing badge/severity styling rather than inventing
new CSS. Room reserved for the future one-click fix action.
- **Storage card** - add disk error / SMART predictive failure to the existing
card rather than a new one.
- **Storage card** - superseded. Disk health shipped in Phase 2 as its own
"Disk health" card (position 18, directly under Storage) instead of being
folded in: Storage is per volume, disk health is per physical device, so they
do not share a key. Rows sort failure-first, then unknown, then OK - a failing
drive must not sit below the fold on a multi-disk box, and a drive that
stopped answering is a weaker claim of health than one that said OK.
- **Windows Update card** - BLOCKED, not scheduled. Depends on Phase 2 data
that is pinned pending a COM-interference investigation. Do not build the card
until the collection question is settled.

View File

@@ -68,6 +68,17 @@ arrays. `adopt` is first-contact only.
"osinfo": { /* opaque object: build, version, install date */ },
"domain": "shopfloor.example.com", // domain or workgroup membership
"pendingreboot": false, // omit when unknown; absent != false
"diskhealth": [ // per PHYSICAL device; see notes
{
"deviceid": "0",
"model": "Samsung SSD 990 PRO 1TB",
"mediatype": "SSD",
"bustype": "NVMe",
"healthstatus": "Healthy",
"predictfailure": false, // precomputed; null = drive did not answer
"source": "physicaldisk" // or "diskdrive"
}
],
"usercontext": { // omitted entirely when nobody is signed in
"netuse": [
{
@@ -133,6 +144,22 @@ Notes:
genuinely empty now"; omit when you simply did not collect it this cycle.
- `pendingreboot` follows that rule strictly: omit it when the check failed. A
literal `false` asserts the endpoint is confirmed NOT holding a reboot.
- `diskhealth` is per PHYSICAL device and is NOT the same list as `disks`, which
is per volume. One physical drive can back several volumes or none the
operator sees, so the two do not share a key and are not merged.
- `diskhealth` carries BOTH agent sources and the server does not reconcile
them. `source: "physicaldisk"` is MSFT_PhysicalDisk, the only source that
reports NVMe at all - the classic ATA SMART class
(`MSStorageDriver_FailurePredictStatus`) returns zero instances on an NVMe
machine, so an agent collecting only that would report an empty health list on
modern hardware and look like "no problems". `source: "diskdrive"` is
Win32_DiskDrive.Status, covering ATA/SATA and hosts where the Storage
namespace is unavailable. When both answer for one drive and disagree, both
rows are shown; that disagreement is the signal.
- `predictfailure` is precomputed by the agent so an alert is a boolean test
rather than a string match against a Windows enum the server would have to
keep in sync. `null` means the drive did not answer: unknown, NOT healthy.
`healthstatus` keeps the human-readable source value alongside it.
- `usercontext` is gathered by a probe the agent runs inside the signed-in
user's session, because mapped drives, user-owned listeners and idle time do
not exist in the agent's own LocalSystem session 0. It is omitted when no one